I personally find this challenging, because much of their grievances are the same tired litany of complaints (only the names and towns have been changed). As a white man, what more can I learn that I haven't already? Some of it is tweaked a little, but in essence, it's not much different. The white man invented AIDS to infect blacks is now taking the place of, white politicians do not want to invest in inner city schools because they want to keep the black man down. And there's no way I can respond, because if I do, one or two things (or both) will likely happen.
First, whenever whites are prepared to engage in a discussion, they must listen. And listen. And listen. Because if they try to add to the discussion by communicating their perceptions, they run the risk of being branded as racists.
If self-proclaimed civil rights leaders like Jesse Jackson or Al Sharpton say something that is asinine and a white person criticizes it, they are branded as racist. If a sitting US Senator that happens to be white describes Obama as an intelligent, "articulate" guy, he is branded a racist. (Remember, when you call a black articulate, that is a racist code word implying that most blacks aren't.) If a former Democratic Congresswoman (one that has a long stellar record on civil rights) says that if everything was equal with Obama except for his race he would not be where he is at in this presidential race, she is demonized in such a hostile manner and branded a racist.
Well, if what I have said so far has you seething and you are ready to write me off as another racist, you may want to read what Robert Johnson has said.
Wading back into the Democratic presidential race, billionaire businessman Bob Johnson said Monday that Sen. Barack Obama would not be his party's leading candidate if he were white.
Johnson's comments to the Observer echoed those of former vice presidential candidate Geraldine Ferraro. She stepped down as an adviser to Sen. Hillary Clinton last month after saying Obama wouldn't be where he is if he were white.
Bob Johnson is not some elitist billionaire white man, he is black. He is not some "Uncle Tom sell-out" that lives exclusively in a white man's world, he founded BET. So, just try and tell Bob he cannot make it in America because he is black. Just make an attempt to tell him the white man is keeping him down. See how hard he laughs you right out of his office suite. Better yet, let's hear the Obama hacks villify him and brand him as a racist.
The second thing that happens when a white person tries to engage in a discussion on race is not as hostile, but it is portrayed as some deep intrinsic concept. Whenever whites try to put themselves in the place of blacks and genuinely understand, they are told they can't possibly fully comprehend the suffering. Why? Because it's a black thing and there is no way a white person can truly feel the pain of a black person.
Never mind there are whites that have attended predominantly black schools and endured racist remarks and discrimination, along the way. Never mind that in the second grade LA Sunsett spent a year in Honolulu, going to school that had an overwhelming majority of Hawaiian students, and had to endure the term "haole" (Hawaiian version of honky) on a daily basis. None of us can possibly understand what blacks have been made to endure at the hands of the white man of European origin. We just can't.
Folks, here's my point. A dialogue on race can/would only be productive if the people that call for this kind of thing would be willing to listen in return. A conversation has two components, listening and talking. We learn more by listening than talking, and it's probably why we have two ears and one mouth. We cannot advance anything if one side is not willing to listen. We cannot make any real progress if once we hear something we don't like, it gets branded as racist. To resolve a difference we all must be willing to take some criticism with an open mind.
Until we see the day these things can be implemented in an honest and meaningful way, we will continue down the same old tired path.
5 comments:
Never mind there are whites that have attended predominantly black schools and endured racist remarks and discrimination, along the way.
Clearly, LAS, you haven't attended an "African American Studies" class at one of America's universities. If you had, you would know that it's impossible for black people to be racist. Only "the majority" can be racist. This is also the reason why race identity politics is allowed for blacks, hispanics, etc., but not for whites.
I wonder what the purveyors of such idiocy will say when whites are no longer the majority. Will they be prepared to accept "White Power!" and White Entertainment Television, and white people demanding preferential treatment?
I'm with you, man. I don't need a discussion on race. What I need is the opposite. My daughter asked me last year, "Dad, is Big Papi black." "I don't know, and it's not important. What's important is that he's not a Yankee," was my response. We should raise our kids so that they don't notice race or even understand the concept.
Greg
What's important is that he's not a Yankee,"
Don't you mean "he's not a Yankee fan?"
LOL, Greg. Was it you who buried his jersey in Yankee Stadium? ;-)
LA, you've hit the nail again. I think it's pretty obvious that Barack deflected this whole embarrassing Wright episode with his national dialogue knowing such a thing tends to freeze white people in their tracks. Not saying I'm too old to learn, far from it, but I don't like stunts.
//We should raise our kids so that they don't notice race or even understand the concept.//
Nice ideal, but unless things change drastically quickly, it's going to remain one of the lost episodes for Fantasy Island.
//I think it's pretty obvious that Barack deflected this whole embarrassing Wright episode with his national dialogue knowing such a thing tends to freeze white people in their tracks.//
But the seeds of doubt have already been planted.
Post a Comment